Can I have the answer for this question plz EGR 2021 Final E
 Can I have the answer for this question, plz
Solution
Case 1 : QH = 9 KW , QL = 9 KW , W = 0 KW
I law of Thermodynamics , Energy balance , -------- QH = QL+W
9 = 9 + 0 ------ Hence, 1 Law of Thermodynamics is satisfied
Although work ouput = 0 , still , 2nd Law of thermodynamics not violated
Case 2 : QH = 10 KW , QL = 5 KW , W = 5 KW
I law of Thermodynamics , Energy balance , -------- QH = QL+W
10 = 5 + 5 ------ Hence 1 Law of Thermodynamics is satisfied
Here work ouput = 5 , 2nd Law of thermodynamics is also satisfied.
Case 3 : QH = 9 KW , QL = 0 KW , W = 7 KW
I law of Thermodynamics , Energy balance , -------- QH = QL+W
9 /= 0 + 7 ------ Hence 1 Law of Thermodynamics is not satisfied.
Also QL = 0 , work is produced without rejecting heat to sink, Hence 2nd law of thermodynamics also violated.
Case 4 : QH = 6 KW , QL =3 KW , W = 4 KW
I law of Thermodynamics , Energy balance , -------- QH = QL+W
6 /= 3 + 4 ------ Hence 1 Law of Thermodynamics is not satisfied.
Also here W+QL = 3+4=7 which is greater than QL = 6, which is against the 2nd law of thermodynamics , hence 2nd law is violated.

