We want to determine whether or not the arguments below are
We want to determine whether or not the arguments below are valid. You need to do the following:
Define predicates & predicate variable(s). e.g., P(x) and Q(x)
Rewrite the argument formally.
Indicate whether the argument form that you have defined is valid with a justification.
A)
No insect is huge
A Griffinfly is huge
Therefore, a Griffinfly is not an insect
B)
All honest people pay their taxes.
Michael pays his taxes.
Therefore, Michael is honest.
Solution
A)p(x)=no insect is huge,
Q(x)=A griffinfly is huge,
Therefore a griffinfly is not insect. ( Valid argument)
B) p(x)= all honest people pay their taxes,
Q(x)=Michael pays his taxes,
Therefore, Michael is honest. Valid argument
