Analyze this inductive reasoning using the strategies set ou

Analyze this inductive reasoning using the strategies set out in the “Evaluating Inductive Arguments” box on p. 5 of Unit 3.3 Lecture Notes:

1-Planed Parenthood is like a religious organization. A religious organization is an organization that preaches a message to the surrounding community. Planned Parenthood is similar in that it advocates a message to the surrounding community. The separation of church and state prohibits religious organizations from receiving federal funding. So, Planned Parenthood should not receive federal funding. (Background Note: Planned Parenthood is a family planning and women\'s health organization.)

2. “The constant presence of male power and control in the life of every woman is what leads me to say that all women are, like me, hookers. A woman in a bank or a restaurant is working for an agreed upon payment. However the bank or restaurant is no different from the streets in male control of payment for work done. On the streets, pimps set the prices for all hookers for a particular service. Regardless of whether a hooker works for a pimp or not, she is in trouble if she overcharges or under charges, relative to this fee schedule. Only men can be pimps. It is not possible for a woman to break through the “ceiling” that separates pimps from hookers. How is this situation different from that in a bank or restaurant?

2-“The constant presence of male power and control in the life of every woman is what leads me to say that all women are, like me, hookers. A woman in a bank or a restaurant is working for an agreed upon payment. However the bank or restaurant is no different from the streets in male control of payment for work done. On the streets, pimps set the prices for all hookers for a particular service. Regardless of whether a hooker works for a pimp or not, she is in trouble if she overcharges or under charges, relative to this fee schedule. Only men can be pimps. It is not possible for a woman to break through the “ceiling” that separates pimps from hookers. How is this situation different from that in a bank or restaurant?

I rented my body out for sexual services while other women rent out their talents for counting money or clearing tables. Or women may be wives at home or wives that go home after work in order to work again under male controlled situations. I did sex work, but then, so does a woman in an office that is required to look pleasing to men in appearance and is subject to sexual harassment. And so, I maintain, all women are hookers.”

(Terri-Lee d’Aaron, “I’m a Hooker: Every Woman’s Profession”, excerpted from Teays “Second Thoughts”, p. 229, Mayfield Pub.)

Solution

what exactly you want is not mentioned for the first part.

-----------

“The constant presence of male power and control in the life of every woman is what leads me to say that all women are, like me, hookers. A woman in a bank or a restaurant is working for an agreed upon payment. However the bank or restaurant is no different from the streets in male control of payment for work done. On the streets, pimps set the prices for all hookers for a particular service. Regardless of whether a hooker works for a pimp or not, she is in trouble if she overcharges or under charges, relative to this fee schedule. Only men can be pimps. It is not possible for a woman to break through the “ceiling” that separates pimps from hookers. How is this situation different from that in a bank or restaurant?

I don\'t think that saying \"The constant presence of male power and control in the life of every woman is what leads me to say that all women are, like me, hookers.\" is appropriate because a hooker rents her body out for sexual services just to earn some money while the women working in the bank or restaurant rent their talent NOT their body for earning money. This is the main difference between a normal women and a hooker. There can be some particular cases where women working in the bank or restaurant to sell their body to save their job but that is not true for all offices or restaurants .