Hi I need help with my Product Development Management assign

Hi, I need help with my Product Development Management assignment..

Q1: Perform concept screening for the four pencil holder concepts shown. Assume the pencil holders are for a member of a product development team who is continually moving from site to site. Clam Shell Screw Cap Slider Zip Pouch Q2: Repeat Q1, but use concept scoring

Solution

The criteria for performing concept screening for the pencil holders to be used by a member of a product development team are as follows :accessibility , being handy, reliable to store,flexible in size to ensure enough storage space,material durability, safety to hold properly without losing during travel, production cost, so on. We can take a maximum of 20 points of criteria. As of for this case we can consider 7 points as mentioned above. We can give scores +1,0,-1 for worst, same and better values for the 7 points mentioned above.

____

-3

Hence we can suggest clam shell to be a pencil holder that can be used by a member of product development team

Criteria	Base option	Zip pouch	Screw cap	Clam shell	Slider
Accessibilty	0	+1	+1	+1	+1
Being handy	0	+1	+1	+1	+1
Reliability to store	0	+1	+2	+3	-1
Size fit enough for storage	0	+2	+1	+2	-2
Material durability	0	+1	+1	+4	-1
Safety to hold pencils without missing or coming out	0	+2	+1	+4	-2
Peoduction cost	0	+1	+1	-1	+1
____
_____
Total	0	+9	+9	+14	-3