Logical Fallocies P1 All college students have pet monkeys P

Logical Fallocies

P1: All college students have pet monkeys.

P2: Janice is a college student.

C: Janice has a pet monkey.

Valid and Sound

Valid but not Sound

Not Valid, but Sound

Not Valid, Not Sound.

The answer Valid and Sound was found the be the wrong answer. Please give correct answer. and reason why.

Solution

Based on the premise that all college students have pet monkeys , as Janice is a college student, must have a pet monkey is valid , but it is unlikely , so the correct answer is VALID BUT NOT SOUND.